2017: Smuttynose vs Flying Fish

2017 Brewbracket Opening Round of 32

Vote!

Smuttynose Brewing Company   VS   Flying Fish
The winner is ... Flying Fish
Smuttynose
49% (78 votes)
Flying Fish
51% (80 votes)
Total votes: 158

New Hampshire's favorite brewery faces off against New Jersey's biggest brewery in this match-up. Smuttynose and Flying Fish are both fan favorites, but only one can win this round of the Odessa Brewbracket.

Named for Smuttynose Island off the craggy New Hampshire coast, Smuttynose Brewery makes 32 well-varied beers in their lineup, from IPAs to a canned Short Weisse series. Many of their beers are rooted in history: like their signature Pinniped Special (their version of the 1841 Vienna lager originally brewed by Anton Dreher), the Old Brown Dog (the 1989 silver medal winner of the American Brown Ale category at the Great American Beer Festival in Denver), and many more! Nonetheless, Smuttynose's competition Flying Fish is no joke. Flying Fish is now one of the largest of the 70+ craft breweries in New Jersey, producing six sustainable, year-round beers, such as their baltic porter and pale ale. Flying Fish's beer selection offers a nuanced experience for one's tastebuds, bringing forth aromatic spices and big flavor.

Vote for your favorite brewery and win!

Both Smuttynose and Flying Fish need your vote if they're going to advance to the next round!  

Click on the logos above to get more info on these cool brews, and be sure to vote for your favorite. Like the match-ups on Facebook or Twitter to be entered to win prizes at this year's Brewfest on September 9th. Every vote counts!

 

Check out the other Matchups

2026 Brewbracket Opening Round of 32

local delaware craft beer company   VS   Fiddlehead Logo

Voting is still open.

Vote now!


Matchup ends August 7, 2026, 10:30 am
Big Oyster Brewery   VS   founders Luke Bowen and Trevor Hayward met in an accounting class at Villanova University

Voting is still open.

Vote now!


Matchup ends August 7, 2026, 10:30 am
Wilmington Brew Works' family-friendly taproom   VS   Tröegs Independent Brewing

Voting is still open.

Vote now!


Matchup ends August 7, 2026, 10:30 am
a local small-batch, experimental brewery located in Newark, Delaware   VS   unwavering commitment to artisanal production practices

Voting is still open.

Vote now!


Matchup ends August 7, 2026, 10:30 am
2SP Brewing Company   VS   Two hands crossed and pointing to Two Roads

Voting is still open.

Vote now!


Matchup ends August 8, 2026, 10:30 am
 line of ales and seasonal brews   VS   Cigar City Brewing Logo

Voting is still open.

Vote now!


Matchup ends August 8, 2026, 10:30 am
a tasty menu of year-round brews including Not Today Satan   VS   Heavy Seas Brewery was established by Hugh Sisson in 1995

Voting is still open.

Vote now!


Matchup ends August 8, 2026, 10:30 am
a fixture in Lewes, Delaware, offering up a selection of delicious brews   VS   the finest Belgian inspired and experimental ales this side of the Atlantic

Voting is still open.

Vote now!


Matchup ends August 8, 2026, 10:30 am
boundaries for the craft of brewing are limitless   VS   beer with complex, in-your-face ales, with huge aromatics, bigger body, and tons of flavor

Voting is still open.

Vote now!


Matchup ends August 9, 2026, 10:30 am
beers and food   VS   fresh, delicious, local beer in South Jersey

Voting is still open.

Vote now!


Matchup ends August 9, 2026, 10:30 am
the first brewery in Middletown, Delaware volunteer brewing co   VS   Levante Brewing Company logo

Voting is still open.

Vote now!


Matchup ends August 9, 2026, 10:30 am
a selection of IPAs, blondes and ales   VS   Victory Brewing

Voting is still open.

Vote now!


Matchup ends August 9, 2026, 10:30 am

Check out the completed matchups

2025 Brewbracket Final Matchup

2025 Brewbracket Semifinal Round

2025 Brewbracket Quarterfinal Round

2025 Brewbracket Round of 16

2025 Brewbracket Opening Round of 32